5 Reasons counter offers are particularly harmful in the ecology sector

Justin Ayling • July 7, 2026

5 Reasons counter offers are particularly harmful in the ecology sector

Counteroffers are common across the ecology and environmental consultancy sector, particularly in a candidate-short market where experienced ecologists, senior ecologists, principal ecologists and technical specialists are in high demand.

At first, a counteroffer can feel like a quick solution and even give the person planning to leave a bit of a buzz...”wow, I feel loved and important again”!

A candidate resigns, the employer increases their salary, and the immediate problem appears to be resolved. However, in ecology recruitment, counter offers often create longer-term issues for both candidates and employers in this extremely close nit community.

Whether you are an ecologist considering a new role or an environmental consultancy trying to retain staff, here are five reasons to be extremely cautious with counter offers.

1. Counter offers rarely solve the real problem

Most ecology candidates do not start looking for a new role purely because of salary. Pay may be part of the decision, but it is rarely the only reason.

Ecologists often move roles because they want better project variety, clearer progression, stronger technical development, improved flexibility, better leadership, a healthier workload or more support with licences and career development.

A counteroffer may increase the salary, but it rarely fixes the underlying reason the candidate started exploring the ecology job market in the first place. Equally, why would a company want to retain someone who clearly wants to leave?

2. They can damage trust between candidate and employer

Once a candidate resigns, the relationship often changes. Even if their current employer increases their salary, the business now knows they were prepared to leave.

That can create doubts around loyalty, commitment, and long-term intentions. It can also leave the candidate questioning why their value was only recognised after they handed in their resignation.

If the salary increase was possible after resignation, why was it not addressed earlier?

3. They can harm a hard-earned reputation

The ecology sector is small. Everyone knows someone who knows someone.

Hiring managers, technical directors, recruiters, consultants, clients and project teams often cross paths across environmental consultancies, infrastructure schemes, local authorities and specialist ecology teams.

It does not take much to tarnish a hard-earned reputation. When a candidate accepts a new ecology role and then pulls out because of a counteroffer, that decision can be remembered.

Reputation in ecology recruitment is built on trust, communication and doing things properly.

4. They leave the new employer frustrated

When a candidate accepts a new role and then withdraws at the final stage, the new employer is left frustrated.

They may have invested time in interviews, technical conversations, salary approvals, offer preparation and internal planning. In some cases, they may have paused their search or turned away other suitable ecology candidates because they believed the offer had been accepted in good faith.

For candidates, this can affect future opportunities. For employers, it can delay projects, increase recruitment pressure and damage confidence in the hiring process.

5. Counter offers set a dangerous precedent for employers

For environmental consultancies, counteroffers can send the wrong message internally.

If an ecologist only receives a pay rise, promotion, or improved package after resigning, it tells the wider team that the best way to progress is to threaten to leave.

Employees do talk. If one person receives a counteroffer, others may begin to question their own salary, progression, and value to the business. This can quickly create resentment or encourage more employees to test the market.

Strong ecology consultancies retain people through regular conversations around salary, progression, workload, flexibility, project exposure, and technical development — not last-minute reactions.

The better approach

For candidates, the best approach is to be clear and honest about motivations before accepting a new role. Only commit to an offer if the intention is genuinely to move.

For employers, the key is to address concerns before someone resigns. Regular salary reviews, clear progression routes, better communication, and proper retention conversations are far more effective than reactive counter offers.

By the time a counteroffer is needed, the real damage may already have been done.

If you are an ecologist considering your next move, or an environmental consultancy looking to hire or retain ecology talent, working with a specialist ecology recruitment firm can help you approach the process properly from the start.

< Older Post

How to Position Yourself for Promotion in the Ecology Sector

By Justin Ayling • June 2, 2026

How to Position Yourself for Promotion in the Ecology Sector As a specialist ecology recruiter, Embankment Group places around 200 ecologists into permanent and freelance roles in the UK and Ireland every year. One thing we hear far too oAn is that ecologists do not always know what they need to do to get promoted. They may be working hard, delivering strong technical work and supporting projects, but still feel unclear on what the next step actually requires. This simply must change. The ecology sector requires transparency, clear progression routes and strong support for ecologists who want to develop. If ecologists are expected to grow into Senior, Principal, Associate or Director level roles, they need to understand exactly what good looks like and what evidence they need to show. Promotion is about Readiness, not time served Promotion in ecology is not just about the number of years you have been in the role (time served). It is about showing that you are ready to take on more responsibility, support others and add value beyond your own workload. If you are aiming for the next step, whether that is Senior Ecologist, Principal Ecologist, Associate or beyond, you need to think about how you are presenting to the person or people responsible for deciding if you are ready for the next step. Know exactly what promotion looks like at any moment in time If you want to be promoted, you need to know exactly what you are being measured against. It should not be vague or based on guesswork. Ask your manager to clearly outline what you need to do, what competencies you need to show and what evidence they would need to see before you can move up. This should almost work like a tick sheet, covering areas such as technical ability, project management, report writing, client communication, mentoring, commercial awareness and business development, depending on the level you are aiming for. At every moment, you should know where you stand. You should know what you have already demonstrated, what still needs to be improved and what specific actions will help you qualify for promotion. This also makes career conversations much easier. Instead of simply saying you feel ready for the next level, you can point to clear examples and show that you have met the agreed expectations. Promotion should not feel like a mystery. The clearer the criteria, the easier it is to focus your development and build a strong case for progression. Build evidence of your impact One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming their hard work will speak for itself. In reality, managers are busy and may not always see the full extent of what you are doing. Keep track of the projects you have supported on, the surveys you have led, the reports you have written and any positive feedback from clients or colleagues. If you have helped deliver work on time, improved quality or supported junior team members, make sure you can clearly evidence it. Show commercial awareness As ecologists move into more senior roles, technical ability is only part of the picture. Employers want to see that you understand project budgets, deadlines, client expectations and resourcing. You do not need to be winning work overnight, but you should be able to show that you understand how your role fits into the wider business. Taking ownership of project delivery, communicating risks early and thinking ahead can make a big difference. Take on responsibility before you ask for it (or you’re asked to!) Promotion often comes when you are already operating at the next level. That might mean mentoring junior ecologists, reviewing reports, managing small projects or becoming the go to person for a particular survey area or technical specialism. Look for opportunities to step up, even in small ways. The more you can show you are already trusted with higher level responsibility, the stronger your case becomes. Communicate your ambitions clearly It is important to have open conversations with your line manager about your career goals. Do not wait until review time to mention that you want to progress. You should be able to meet your manager casually to review your progress. A single annual review doesn’t really cut the mustard. If this is the case, I would recommend talking to you Line Manager or HR team to review this. Ask what you need to demonstrate to move up, what gaps you need to close and what support is available. This gives you a clearer route forward and helps your manager understand that progression matters to you. Keep developing your technical profile In ecology, specialist skills can really strengthen your promotion case. Survey licences, protected species experience, botany skills, Biodiversity Net Gain knowledge, EcIA experience and project management capability can all help you stand out. Think about which skills are most valuable to your team and where you can become more useful to the business. Final thoughts Positioning yourself for promotion is about more than doing a good job. It is about showing leadership, commercial awareness, technical growth and a clear willingness to take on more responsibility. If you feel you are already operating above your current level, start gathering evidence, have the right conversations and make it easy for your employer to see the value you bring.